fr en de
portrait

Without Europe, there can be no peace in Ukraine

The « coalition of the willings », comprising 37 states, has just organised major manoeuvres on the Ukrainian border (the ‘Koalicja’ exercise), the European Political Community, with its 47 members, adopted an unprecedented declaration on its security in Dublin, and Europeans marked the end of the fighting in 1918, whilst further talks between the Russians and Ukrainians, alongside the Americans, took place in Abu Dhabi. This may well be a historic moment. Greater Europe, broader than the European Union alone, is taking shape.


Russia refuses to allow Europeans to take part in negotiations with Ukraine. Ukraine wants this, and the United States accepts it.


How, indeed, can one imagine attempting to redraw a border on the continent without the European states?


The aggressor wishes to demonstrate that it remains a great power capable of imposing peace or war – a status it now holds only through its capacity to cause harm. It is making an ever-increasing number of the most excessive demands, hoping, as is its custom, that Westerners acting in good faith will make a concession in its favour.


The Trump administration takes a detached and mercantile view of this horrific conflict, apparently eager to resume trade Russia. Nevertheless, its emissaries seem finally to have realised that they do not hold the keys to resolving these tragic disputes and that only Europe’s presence at the negotiating table might make this possible.


Modern-day Ukraine will never agree to relinquish its independence, sovereignty or territory. Nor will Europeans accept Russia’s demand for a new security architecture to replace the one that the invasion of Ukraine destroyed, following other breaches of commitments (Georgia, Moldova, Crimea). Russia’s credibility is in question. Only increased aid to Ukraine, which has been attacked, and – once peace has been restored – solid security guarantees for the country, will make it possible to envisage a return to lasting peace.


Europe is the only party capable of providing these, and perhaps one day of convincing Russia that peace and stability offer its best chance of catching up. Putin’s stance, which is closed to any discussion, sadly suggests instead that only the language of force – which Europe has, wisely, refrained from using until now – will bring him to the negotiating table.


Whatever observers and critics may say, by stepping in to replace US support, Europe has already demonstrated that it has the determination to do so, as its own security is at stake. It therefore does not deserve this condemnation, which is largely influenced by Russian propaganda.


And whatever approach the Europeans adopt, they will play an indispensable role in resolving this conflict.


 

signature